Don’t totally discard Michael Vaughan
“The best thing for me is to try and get back to being best batsmen I can be.”
Fair point. If they didn’t have to drop you, you wouldn’t be losing the captaincy and if you scored more runs, maybe the series would have gone better.
Michael Vaughan now knows that everything isn’t scripted especially for him.
He had to convince everyone he could successfully come back from injury a year ago. He made a hundred in his first innings back. That probably sent him over.
All the effort, all the hard work was instantly vindicated. Put that into the head of a captain who’d received one too many plaudits for an unexpected Ashes win and he maybe gets a bit ahead of himself.
Vaughan never makes runs in county cricket, but tells himself and us that he’s above that. He’s not.
An element of complacency seems to have set in - certainly in his own game. It was always a magic ball. A big score was always just round the corner. Maybe he didn’t really mean it when he said things like that, but it certainly seemed like he did.
Michael Vaughan was a great captain, but like most British sports people, he only really paid lip service to the philosophy of constant improvement that’s the hallmark of true success. Either that or he responded to pressure and criticism in an arrogant way that gave that impression.
If it’s the latter, he’s screwed. That basically just means that he’s not good enough and gets a bit defensive about his shortcomings.
If he did just get a bit lazy, then at least there’s something he can do about it - and he’s the kind of guy who would do something about it. His pride’s been clean bowled first ball and Vaughan’s a proud man.
Half-cut and half-asleep. We’ll come back to this another time.
Shove Michael Vaughan down to number six - that’s where England keep their worst batsman.


It was far from a classic Test match. It felt like it was mapped out from the start and the players were just doing what they were expected to do.