1990s Ashes Rematch: England bat first on day 1

Posted by
4 minute read

Last month we pitted a 90s England XI against a 90s Australia XI using International Cricket Captain’s ‘All Time Greats’ mode and the Aussies won. This is the rematch Down Under.

A quick recap. These teams are not 1990s best XIs. They are 1990s-est XIs. Here’s our workings-out.

In short, the Australia XI for this match is the same as for the first match, because that is still the most 90s XI. The England XI is quite a bit different because that’s how picking 90s England sides works.

The match will unfold a day at a time. As you have already deduced through the power of reading, today is day one.

The toss

Tails never fails.

Fortunately Mike Atherton is captain, not Nasser Hussain, so England opt to bat.

Looks like there’ll be a touch of variable bounce. Wonder whether it’ll flatten out.

Morning session

Atherton walks to the crease, Alec Stewart marches in alongside him.

The first 10 overs are pretty calm. Stripped of the keeping gloves and shoved up the order, Stewart strokes three fours, including a beaut straight back over Paul Reiffel’s head.

There’s the faintest hint of a run-out chance too, but prancing gazelle Athers makes his ground easily.

For somewhat mysterious reasons, Steve Waugh gets an over. Brendon Julian beats Stewart outside off.

England reach 50 without loss. Stewart crashes a couple more fours.

At lunch, England are 67-0 and Steve Waugh’s bowled two more overs.

Back in England, fans retire to bed awash with joy and optimism and also the knowledge that they’ll probably feel completely different about five minutes after they wake up in the morning.

Afternoon session

England’s first scoring stroke after lunch is just about the most incredible shot ever played.

Athers does this…

And it goes through extra cover for four.

“Un-bloody-believable,” says Jonathan Agnew on commentary.

Aware it would be impossible to improve on that shot, England decide to progress almost entirely in singles. Stewart reaches 50.

Australia’s attack is looking either samey or like Colin Miller, but then Alec Stewart puts his bat everywhere but into a gun barrel straight Paul Reiffel delivery and is bowled for 71.

Graeme Hick is next man in. He made 88 and 69 in our first 1990s Ashes match.

Athers reaches his 50. He could make 400 and it wouldn’t top that shot from before.


It’s been slow going, but nothing is terrible for England yet.

Evening session

Fourth ball after tea, Athers backs away and under-edges Damien Fleming to Ian Healy for a round 50.

That would have missed leg by about six inches. Quite why he was trying to cut it is anyone’s guess. Maybe he felt like he could do anything in the wake of The Shot.

Nasser Hussain hustles in, looking intense.

Hick’s bat sounds like it has a crack or the handle’s coming loose or something, but he’s hitting them nicely all the same.

Until he isn’t. Fleming goes round the wicket and Hick unfurls a forward defensive that would have been late had Fleming been bowling spin. He’s bowled for 30 off 37.

Graham Thorpe ambles in, looking slightly dishevelled but determined.

Haunted by memories of England batting collapses past, Hussain and Thorpe spend half an hour refusing to score runs.

Even Healy’s out-scoring them, failing to wrap his gloves around a fairly innocuous Reiffel delivery and conceding four byes.

Hussain finally hits an intense boundary off his 55th ball and moves to 16. Thorpe is on nine off 51.

Next over Hussain intensely nurdles Waugh for four more. The new ball has been available for a couple of overs already. Finally Australia take it.

It changes nothing. Australia’s bowlers don’t threaten. England continue to score in pathetic drips. Hussain hits one more intense four.


It’s the kind of score you’d expect to see at the tea break.

Could be better, could be worse. That goes for both sides.

Join us tomorrow for day two.


Mike Gatting wasn't receiving the King Cricket email when he dropped that ludicrously easy chance against India in 1993.


Why risk it when it's so easy to sign up?


  1. Hick has had a partial failure, better drop him for a couple of matches so he gets his confidence back.

  2. In my head, Fred Trueman is summarising.

    According to Wikipedia his daughter married Raquel Welsh’s son. Can that be true?

  3. I suppose its more 1990’s-ish to have a half-decent Day 1, raise hopes and then collapse on Day 2 and end up losing by an innings and loads of runs.

    1. Actually, if this is the last match of an Ashes series and the Aussies have already retained the Ashes, it is very, very 1990s for England to win.

      That allows bucket-loads of English false hope and expectation to subsist, possibly for as long as thirty months.

      On that basis, I’m expecting England to win this match.

  4. Very good point.
    Its more 2000’s, 2010’s to lose 5-0.
    Its more 1990’s to lose the first 3, draw the next and then win the last 1.
    But by the time the next Ashes comes they’re about no.7 in the Test rankings so all hope is gone.

  5. Has Atherton already played the shot in the picture, or is he just about to? It looks a bit like he’s trying to snooker-cue it back past the bowler.

  6. 205 for 3 at stumps on Day 1. This is the greatest day in 90s English cricket history! We’ve got tons of batting / some batting / at least one batsman / Robin Smith yet to come. And then we’ve got Lewis, Gough and Fraser to tear into them, and Ian Salisbury to mop up the remnants with the old ball.

    1. Would that be England’s version of Roberts, Holding, Garner and Croft doing the tearing?

  7. Was AB de Villiers around in the 1990’s?
    Even Mr360 would have been impressed with that.

Comments are closed.